A Crucial Second Opinion
Mr. Swift* arrived for his “second opinion” consultation with the requested folder of medical reports, neuropsychological assessments, lab results, and MRI disks. In his initial meeting with another physician, he had been told that his troubling forgetfulness was due to Alzheimer’s disease (AD), and that this condition would likely progress to disability. He was advised to consider his approaching decline as he and his dear family planned for their future. He began to plan an exit from his thriving business. At age 62, in what he had considered his prime, this was terrifying news.
He wanted a second opinion, and that is how he found me. A careful evaluation of his history, health status, and thorough prior evaluations couldn’t rule out the possibility of AD, although his age of onset was young and some symptoms were not typical.
After some discussion, we agreed he should have an amyloid PET scan, even though it would have to be purchased without insurance coverage. The reassuring negative scan indicated that he did not have AD or very early AD. The negative scan results indicated that it was important to look for other causes of cognitive difficulty (such as vitamin deficiency or mercury toxicity), which prompted further medical assessment and identified issues that were treated aggressively. Mr. Swift’s cognition improved and stabilized, and several years after these events he continues to enjoy an independent and active life.
What is PET?
PET, or Positron Imaging Tomography, is a nuclear medicine neuroimaging tool that can be used to make a picture of amyloid plaque accumulation within a person’s brain. Amyloid can accumulate with age in a brain that is functioning normally, and it can be seen in diseases other than AD, but the presence of a positive amyloid scan in a symptomatic individual is a strong indicator of the AD diagnosis. In this type of scan, specially prepared tracer molecules are injected intravenously. They travel through the blood to the brain and attach to amyloid plaques. The radiation they send out can be used to create a picture that tells us the density and location of plaques. Tracers of this type have already been used as research tools, and the FDA has recently approved several for clinical use.
How is PET Used?
Amyloid PET scanning has already revolutionized clinical research. For many clinical drug trials, a positive amyloid scan is now required prior to enrollment. This way, investigators can be more certain they are treating people who truly have AD. When subjects are screened in this way prior to treatment, the effectiveness of a new medication is more likely to be recognized.
The clinical roles for amyloid PET scanning remain much less clear at this time. A group of experts met to discuss this and published their recommendations in 2011.1 They suggested that these scans should be used clinically when the results would make a difference in treatment. The groups of patients whose treatment might be changed in a helpful way by a PET amyloid scan result include:
- Patients with persistent or progressive and unexplained mild cognitive impairment (now called mild neurocognitive disorder)
- Patients diagnosed with possible AD but with unusual features such as rapid course, unexpected symptoms or concurrent medical issues
- Patients with unusually early onset of dementia who might benefit from different treatment or from referral to a clinical trial on the basis of a scan result
On the other hand, the consensus group discouraged use of amyloid imaging for patients whose management would not be likely to benefit, including:
- Patients with typical AD symptoms, age of onset, and course
- Patients without symptoms or whose symptoms are not confirmed by clinical examination
- Patients seeking to know their risk for AD because of various concerns including family history of dementia or presence of a particular version of the ApoE gene, or patients with a strong family history of early-onset AD seeking an alternative to gene testing.
- Individuals being screened for insurance coverage, employment, or other nonmedical purposes
Researchers have already begun to see whether the results of amyloid PET scanning have practical benefits in clinical use. Grundman and colleagues, for example, recently published results from a study that explored how clinicians might change their treatment plans for patients with positive or negative amyloid scan results.2
For patients with an AD diagnosis and negative scan, cholinesterase medications (such as Aricept, Exelon, and Razadyne) were typically stopped. These medicines can be expensive and sometimes produce uncomfortable side effects, so it is worthwhile to stop prescribing them to patients who will not benefit. For subjects in this study who had carried a non-AD diagnosis but had a positive scan, the diagnosis was typically changed and appropriate medications started. Subjects who learned of their scan results were not more likely to become depressed or anxious. In another study which focused on earlier onset subjects, 18% of patients initially thought to have AD turned out to have negative amyloid scans.3 A negative scan can fuel a more intensive search for treatable causes of cognitive problems, sometimes with results as fortunate as Mr. Swift’s.
A Large Multicenter Trial
A study is currently enrolling patients for amyloid scanning at many locations in the United States. This study is called IDEAS, short for Imaging Dementia—Evidence from Amyloid Scanning. Its objective is to determine how appropriately-ordered PET amyloid scans will affect clinical management, and the results are likely to inform insurers’ decisions regarding coverage of this test. For information about screening for this study, which requires referral from a certified expert to a participating PET facility, please see www.clinicaltrials.gov.4
For Mr. Swift, amyloid PET scanning was a definite game-changer. So far, it looks like these scans can help others as well. The major drawbacks will be clinically appropriate use, scan availability, and expense, but evidence that scan results affect clinical decision-making seems to be accumulating. Whether positive or negative for amyloid accumulation, these scans may help clinicians proceed with greater knowledge and assurance. Patients will be able to have greater confidence in their diagnoses and treatment recommendations. As the development of disease modifying treatments becomes ever more commonplace, a tool that increases diagnostic accuracy will be welcome. Stay tuned for the results of IDEAS and for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ decisions about scan coverage.
*Mr. Swift’s name and details have been changed to protect confidentiality.
- Johnson KA, Minoshima S, Bohnen NI, et al. Appropriate use criteria for amyloid PET: A report of the Amyloid Imaging Task Force, the Society of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging, and the Alzheimer’s Association. Alzheimer’s & Dementia 2013;9:e1-e16.
- Grundman M, Johnson KA, Lu M, et al. Effect of Amyloid Imaging on the Diagnosis and Management of Patients with Cognitive Decline: Impact of Appropriate Use Criteria. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord. 2016;41(1-2):80-92. doi: 10.1159/000441139. Epub 2016 Jan 8.]
- Alzheimer’s Disease Toolkit (Helpful Information to Understand and Manage Alzheimer's Disease)
- Expert Information on Alzheimer's Disease (Articles)
- Diagnostic Tests for Alzheimer's Disease (Article)
- Screening and Diagnosis (Article)
- Treatment and Drug Options for Alzheimer’s Disease (Article)
- Medical Conditions that can Mimic Dementia (Article)
- “Is It Something I'm Taking?” Medications That Can Mimic Dementia (Article)
This content was last updated on: October 2, 2018
The information provided here is a public service of the BrightFocus Foundation and should not in any way substitute for personalized advice of a qualified healthcare professional; it is not intended to constitute medical advice. Please consult your physician for personalized medical advice. BrightFocus Foundation does not endorse any medical product, therapy, or resources mentioned or listed in this article. All medications and supplements should only be taken under medical supervision. Also, although we make every effort to keep the medical information on our website updated, we cannot guarantee that the posted information reflects the most up-to-date research.
These articles do not imply an endorsement of BrightFocus by the author or their institution, nor do they imply an endorsement of the institution or author by BrightFocus.
Some of the content may be adapted from other sources, which will be clearly identified within the article.